The Soapbox

RML Hoos

Joined: 11/04/2004 Posts: 1836
Likes: 2063


Neither the opinion nor the quote from Kagan's dissent says that


administrative law is dismantled and it doesn't say that Congress can't authorize agencies to do all sorts of things. The opinion says the EPA wasn't authorized by an almost never used provision of the Clean Air Act to require a "generation shifting" approach forcing electricity produces to shift power generation from production on one source (coal or natural gas) to new production from a new source (natural gas or renewable).

Kagan disagrees with the opinion, saying that the EPA was authorized by congress to put in place the regulations they implemented.

To comply with this opinion, all congress would have to do is amend the Clean Air Act to authorize the EPA to do something like issue regulations to address climate change including the reduction of greenhouse gasses by requiring industries to shift production sources to those which produce less greenhouse gas emissions.

Really, the Clean Air Act wasn't designed to address climate chance - it was to address air harmful / toxic air pollutants that were immediately and directly harmful to human health. Congress probably just needs to pass a new act all together authorizing the EPA, or other agencies, to address climate change. It was passed in 1963, amended twice in the 70's and for the last time in 1990. We should have some expectation that Congress can act to address things more than once every 30 years? Having the EPA trying to shoehorn regulations into authorizing legislation that is 30-60 years old to address concerns that were just getting onto the radar in 1990 does not make a lot of sense.

I get it that congress has a really hard time getting its act together to do anything - but we shouldn't just cede all authority to the executive because congress has problems. Then all it takes is one executive (Trump) to screw everything up.

(In response to this post by Seattle .Hoo)

Posted: 06/30/2022 at 12:56PM



+0

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:


Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:


Current Thread:
  Or even 50 years. ** -- Seattle .Hoo 06/30/2022 11:58AM
  Quick answer I found is it’s somewhat limited to EPA -- WahooMatt05 06/30/2022 10:43AM
  Either way i'm good or anything that roots out -- Charleston Cav 06/30/2022 10:32AM
  Like crazy Fauci? ** -- WaxHoo 06/30/2022 10:34AM
  That’s as good a place to start as any. No bureaucrat has… -- Los Angeles Hoo 06/30/2022 10:42AM
  Hope you like LA smog, it may make a comeback ** -- Oregon Hoo 06/30/2022 12:08PM
  Bunker? ** -- HoodatB 06/30/2022 11:17AM
  You're hopeless ** -- HptHokie 06/30/2022 10:45AM
  That is total bullshit ** -- 111Balz 06/30/2022 10:44AM
  If I knew how to embed .gifs here, I would embed this one -- southdenverhoo 06/30/2022 11:19AM
  Here (GIF) -- Hoo TV 06/30/2022 11:23AM
  I was wondering the same thing ** -- WahooMatt05 06/30/2022 10:30AM
  Taken to its logical extreme … ** -- WaxHoo 06/30/2022 10:30AM
  Yeah, it seems like it could be bad going forward -- WahooMatt05 06/30/2022 10:54AM
  You really think so? ** -- NJHoo 06/30/2022 11:05AM
  It’s like those Magic Eye photos from the 90s. -- WahooMatt05 06/30/2022 11:25AM

Notice: Trying to get property 'queue' of non-object in /data/www/sportswar.com/wp-includes/script-loader.php on line 2781

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /data/www/sportswar.com/wp-includes/script-loader.php on line 2781
vm307